In 1896 and 7, hundreds of western American newspapers reported mass sightings of fantastic, winged airships performing maneuvers years ahead of the technology of the time. In some cases, the airships landed, and their pilots talked to witnesses. Most Americans assumed a secret inventor would soon take credit for the sightings, but no one who did so could prove ownership of a functional flying machine. The “mystery airships” remain unidentified, constituting an early wave of UFOs before flying saucers, and almost before flight itself.

The “California Airship”

The majority of the sightings occurred over 8 months between mid November, 1896, and the end of April, 1897. There were hundreds of sightings some with thousands of witnesses each, according to newspaper reports. Every attempt to verify the names of witnesses provided in newspaper reports has turned up real people. There were more than 1200 newspaper articles published on the sightings in over 400 papers in 41 states and 6 Canadian provinces.

The first sighting to make the news occurred over Sacramento on November 17. The most obvious feature was a brilliant electrical light. It was not clear the light was mounted to a structure, but some saw an egg-shaped craft with four downward-facing propellers. The San Francisco Call had this image drawn of the craft, based on witness’ descriptions. The object flew by the city over the course of half an hour and made several changes in course, swaying from side to side and up and down, like a boat against a rapid current. It was later reported that a similar light went the opposite direction the following night.

The majority of papers dismissed the sightings, but a few took them seriously. Believers assumed an inventor was testing a new design, and expected him to unveil his craft at any time, but anyone who claimed responsibility, like the lawyer George Collins, or California’s Attorney General, William Henry Harrison Hart, later reneged on their claims.

More sightings occurred in Sacramento on November 22. This time, two lights were seen, apparently anchored to the same structure. Again, those who could see it said that it was egg-shaped, and at least one witness could see moving parts like wings or propellers. Lights were seen in the San Francisco Bay area as well; witnesses included policemen, street-car drivers, car barn employees, their foreman, and a conductor. The mayor of San Francisco vouched for his two servants who said they’d seen lights as well. In the following days, similar lights were seen from San Jose to Tacoma, Washington, and even into Western Canada. Sightings continued into December, and fizzled out by the end of the year. No one took credit for them.

The Airship Returns

The airship story died by mid December, but on February 2, 1897, new sightings emerged in Nebraska, then spread north and east over the next ten weeks. By mid April, the lights were seen over Omaha, with mass sightings over; Kansas city; Nashville, Chicago, and Evanston, Illinois; and Waterloo, Iowa. By April 20 there were sightings in Wisconsin and and Indiana. At the same time, the sightings spread southwest into Texas and Louisiana. By May, they had nearly ceased entirely.

In the majority of cases, witnesses saw only lights, but those who saw structures claimed that the airships reached over 200m in length, though most were between about 10 and 60m long. Airships displayed a wide range of mechanisms for generating lift and propulsion: some contained propellers, and most had wings - curved, straight, flapping or fixed -  though some were suspended from great balloons.

Many witnesses claimed that they spoke with the pilots of landed airships. The first pilot encounter came just two days after the first sightings over Sacramento, on Nov 19: Col. H. G. Shaw claimed to encounter two tall, lanky Martians who flew away silently in a football-shaped craft. The story is likely a hoax - hoaxes directed at uncritical readers were common in 19th-century newspapers - but later stories of “close encounters” weren’t all so far-fetched.

Most reports involved “everyday Americans” who asked for menial favours and boasted of the revolutionary potential of their experimental craft. On April 16, 1897 a C. G. Williams of Greenville, Texas claimed he was asked to mail letters for the crew of a brilliant, lighted airship that landed in a field. The ship was cigar-shaped, with corrugated wings, a fan-like tail, and a propeller at the front. The pilot said that he expected to “revolutionize travel and transportation” when he revealed his craft to the public. Two days later, Colonel Tom Peoples of Milam county, TX saw a giant winged airship that flew like a buzzard cast its shadow over some workers on his farm. It came to a hover over an artificial lake, then unfurled a number of coloured banners, and shot strange “streaks of light” into the air.

In April 1897, J.B. Ligon and his son went to inspect some lights in a nearby pasture, and found four men standing next to a “large dark object” who asked him for water. One man said that his name was Wilson, and that his ship was only one of five aircraft constructed in secret. It had four large wings like a dragonfly, and propellers at its bow and stern. The next day, Sheriff H. W. Baylor met three men outside an airship landed behind his house in Uvalde, Texas, and one identified himself as Wilson of Goshen, New York. There were at least three other incidents in Texas involving a Wilson or other similar elements.

Encounters with crewman got stranger from there. On April 18, a Judge Love of Waxahachie, Texas, claimed he met 5 strangely-dressed men smoking pipes in repose by a landed aircraft. The men said they were from “the land beyond the polar seas,” and that they were descendants of the ten lost tribes of Israel. Their craft was cigar-shaped with three pairs of flapping wings. On April 19, the Dallas Morning News reported a crashed airship at Aurora, Texas. Supposedly, a “Martian” body was recovered, as well as many fragments of metal, although no evidence of this remains today. The same day, a cattle farmer named Alexander Hamilton claimed an airship grabbed one of his cows by noose, and carried it away. He found it apparently dropped in a nearby field, butchered. However, Jerome Clarke has provided testimony from those who claim that they or their family members conspired with Hamilton to perpetrate a hoax, as part of a liar’s club tradition.

Explanations

Those who believed in the reality of the airships were wowed by the sightings. Some interpreted the airships as supernatural omens, and credited them with the current rise in church membership, but most assumed they were experimental aircraft being tested by some secret, Edison-like inventor. In fact, Edison was so widely assumed to be the inventor, he had to make a statement in the papers denying his involvement, and casting doubt on the practicalities of flight.

Denouncers assumed sightings were hoaxes, or hallucinations from bad alcohol. In an effort to prove that people had been duped, the Peoria Transcript sent up a lighted balloon in Illinois, and reported on the many witnesses who thought they had seen an airship. However, none of these witnesses saw any structural features that were not actually there, and the balloon could only move with the wind, though many of the mystery lights had moved against it, and made abrupt changes in course.

Prof. G. W. Hough of Dearborn Observatory made statements to the press claiming that the sightings were caused by atmospheric distortions of the red-hued star Alpha Orionus, or Betelguese, as many had seen a red light on the airship. Other authorities attributed sightings to meteors. But when the sightings ended in the summer of 1897, there was no consensus on what had happened, and the story evaporated from the newspapers. When the writer Frank Edwards and astronomer Jacques Vallée resurrected it in the mid 1960s, it was still an open mystery. The scholarship since comes to no consensus. Daniel Cohen attributes the episode to a bout of public hysteria stirred up by a few journalists’ hoaxes, and supports the contemporary belief that a few railroad workers helped start the prank by relaying fake sightings between stations. The writer Wallace Chariton implies that the airships may have been extraterrestrial spacecraft. Both Michael Busby and J. Allan Danelek conclude that the airships were the test craft of a secret network of experimental aeronauts ruined by some unknown disaster.

Some have attributed the airship sightings to media influence. The airship was then a common element of science fiction, and featured prominently in Jules Verne’s Robur the Conquerer series, as well as the Thomas Edison Jr. and Frank Reade Jr. Series. But the machines in these series more often had propellers, like modern helicopters, and only rarely flapping wings. And science fiction alone can’t explain the timing of the wave, or the patterned geography of sighting reports.

Because scholars cannot agree on an explanation, the mystery airships are typically labelled as UFOs - precursors to the “ghost rockets” and “flying saucers” of the late 1940s - although exactly how they relate to the modern UFO phenomenon is debated. Certainly, there are many similarities between the two waves, especially as they appeared in media.

However, it’s difficult to explain why the airships boasted so many clunky and impractical 19th-century technologies, and so few of the mechanisms proven most effective a few years later. Jacques Vallée explains this fact by suggesting that the UFO phenomenon evolves in appearance over time so as to always reflect the technologies familiar to its witnesses. The airships boasted absurd technologies and  designs by today’s standards, but these were the most advanced that 19th-century Americans could imagine. Still, Vallée’s theories don’t explain what the airships were, or where they came from.

Summary

More than a century later, the origin of the airships is still a mystery. Despite several reports in which airships dropped letters, debris, anchors, and trash, no evidence exists today but the stories in the newspapers. But whether they were real or not, the mystery airships had a strong effect in the media, generating discussion of recent progress in aviation, and spreading hope in human ingenuity. They allowed Americans to discuss the far-reaching impacts that flight would have on war, travel, commerce and transportation, and to get a glimpse of the revolution ahead a few years before they lived it for themselves.

But the airships didn't simply disappear with the introduction of navigable flying machines in the early 20th century. More “phantom airships” were seen over the U.K. in 1909 and 1910, and over the U.K., Germany, Canada, and South Africa in 1912 and 13. Then, their pilots left for good; or maybe they got new ships.

Selected Sources:

• Jacobs, David. The UFO Controversy In America. Indiana University Press, 1975. available at: https://archive.org/stream/DavidJacob...

• Reece, Gregory L (August 21, 2007). UFO Religion: Inside Flying Saucer Cults and Culture. New York:  I. B. Tauris, 2007.

• Daniel Cohen. The Great Airship Mystery: A UFO of the 1890s. New York: Dodd Mead, 1981.

• Wallace Chariton. The Great Texas Airship Mystery. 1991 Rudolph Umland. “Phantom Airships of the Nineties.” Prairie Schooner 12 (winter 1938): 247-260.

• Loren E. Gross. Charles Fort, the Fortean Society, & Unidentified Flying Objects. 2st ed. Fremont, CA: Loren E. Gross, 1976.

• See two of the original newspaper sources here: https://web.archive.org/web/200709271... 

Source: https://www.thinkanomalous.com/mystery-airship-sightings.html

A Minnesota UFO? The 1897 Barnesville mystery 'air ship'

Sightings of UFOs and mystery airships took hold in the 19th and 20th century. One was spotted above a football game in '48. Another 'carried' Martians looking for women's clothes

FARGO — In my last couple few years of doing “Back Then” stories, perhaps no story has garnered more attention than this story from December of 2020 when we looked into one of the region's most famous UFO sightings high above the skies of a North Dakota football stadium on a chilly October night in 1948. It was shared and reshared many times. I even had the chance to talk about it on a UFO podcast out of Spain. That was a first. The story was probably intriguing for a couple of reasons. First, the person who reported the unidentified flying object in north Fargo on Oct. 1, 1948, was a well-respected World War II aviator. His account was deemed so credible that government officials came out to talk to him about in person.

Another reason this story might have attracted attention? If you look at the time and location of the sighting it’s very clear that the alleged UFO would have been tearing through the skies just as a college football game between the North Dakota State University Bison and the Augustana Vikings of 1948 was carrying on below.

I tried my hardest to find anyone who might have played in or attended the game that night, but I wasn’t successful. The youngest players on the team that night would be about 93 years old. Would they remember anything weird going on in the sky above the scrimmage line? Or perhaps any children in the stands that day might still be around today to tell their story. If so, let me know.

Anyway, the story was so interesting and I loved doing every second of it. That’s one reason I was so glad to hear that Markus Krueger of the Clay County Historical Society is doing a presentation at the Moorhead Library that features this sighting, what led up to it and more.

"In the summer of 1947, hundreds of people started seeing what they call 'Flying Saucers,'" Krueger said. "Nobody had ever seen one before, but once somebody came up with the concept of the Flying Saucer, everybody started seeing them."

He's taking a light-hearted look at how pop culture might have influenced what we thought we saw in the skies and even what we called it. For example, while the people in the 1940s called those specks in the sky "flying saucers," more than 50 years earlier in Barnesville, Minnesota, people spotted mysterious "airships." And those accounts are even wilder than what happened in north Fargo a half-century later.

Mysterious airships hover over Barnesville

In the late summer of 1896, North America was captivated by the “last great gold rush” when prospectors discovered gold in the Klondike region of Canada’s Yukon territory. But millions of Americans were less intrigued by what was in “them thar hills” than what was flying above their heads.

From late 1896 to early 1897, from the western United States to the east, America was enthralled by “mystery airships.” A precursor to what became known as unidentified flying objects (UFOS) or today’s preferred term of unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP), mystery airships were described in many different ways. Some people saw them as strange lights in the sky while others said they looked like huge cigarlike dirigibles, birds or strange machines.

The first reports of mystery airships came out of California in November of 1896. In addition to seeing the ship itself, some people on the ground said they spotted occupants riding in the ships. Others said they actually interacted with the occupants, and while they appeared human, there was something “off” about them.

By the spring of 1897, the wave of sightings had spread to the central and eastern United States. Krueger says the airships were spotted in Nebraska by February of 1897, Kansas in March and Minnesota by April.

According to Robert Barthomew in his 1990 book, “The Airship Hysteria of 1896-1897,” the number of total sightings was in the thousands and the total number of witnesses might have exceeded 100,000.

“The more people who said they saw an airship, the more people across the country could swear that they saw airships, too,” said Krueger.

An airship was spotted in Barnesville, Minnesota, on April 14, 1897. Kruger shared two clips from the Barnesville Record-Review from April 15th and 16th.

On April 15, 1897, the newspaper in Barnesville reported that the airship that had been "frightening the people of the Twin Cities" was spotted in Barnesville. Contributed / Markus Krueger

The first paragraph of the story from the 15th starts:

“The airship that has been frightening the people of the Twin Cities for the past week, passed over this place last evening between 8 and 9 o’clock and was visible for nearly thirty minutes and all sorts of ugly rumors are afloat this morning.” 

The story continues by claiming some people were confident they saw the faces of Minnesota state legislators gazing down upon them from the ship.

The story gets even more outrageous the next day claiming that the cigar-shaped object carried Martians who came to Barnesville to get a good deal on ladies' skirts at a local store.

“By far the largest and handsomest assortment ever shown in the city at prices that are within the reach of all, a beauty at $1.75.”

Tongue in cheek

It’s pretty clear, by this point, the journalists and the people supposedly spotting the airships were having a little fun with all of this. Some reporters even tagged out of their story claiming they were writing their account from “an insane asylum.”

But the question remains were any of the airships based in reality? You never know. If UFOs visited Earth in the 20th century, why couldn’t they have visited in the 19th century?

An illustration of an airship spotted in 1897 from the St. Paul Globe.Contributed / St. Paul Globe via Markus Krueger

In his book “Borderlands; The Ultimate Exploration of the Unknown," historian Mike Dash described and summarized the 1896–1897 series of airship sightings, writing:

“The general conclusion of investigators was that a considerable number of the simpler sightings were misidentification of planets and stars, and a large number of the more complex the result of hoaxes and practical jokes. A small residuum remains perplexing.”

If you’re perplexed and want to know more, check out Markus Krueger’s presentation Thursday, Oct. 26, at the Moorhead Library. Let me know if you discover the truth about the ships and why they might have come to Barnesville.

My money is on the ladies' dress sale

Source: https://www.grandforksherald.com/news/the-vault/a-minnesota-ufo-the-1897-barnesville-mystery-air-ship