10 - QFT - Particle Physics 2: Standard Model
In this series Professor Susskind continues his particle physics theme, focusing on the foundations of the Standard Model, which describes the interactions and properties of the observed particles. These lectures cover the basics of group theory, symmetry, symmetry breaking, which are the natural way to describe the known particles. Several lectures are devoted to the way that particles get their mass, popularly known as the Higgs mechanism. (Image credit: Atlas Experiment at the Large Hadron Collider)
In the first lecture of the series Professor Susskind introduces theoretical concepts underlying the standard model. He also gives a zoological overview of the observed particles.
Topics:
Renormalization
The equivalence of particles, fields, and forces
The particle zoo
Summary:
(00:05) The lecture begins by reviewing fundamental concepts in particle physics, including the relationship between fields and their quanta (particles), particle properties like spin, and the distinction between fermions and bosons.
(02:47) It introduces a core "triangle of concepts" that connects particles, fields, and forces. For every elementary particle, there is an associated field, and for every field, there is an associated force.
(05:07) Forces are explained from two perspectives. From a classical field view, the force between two charges is the interaction energy of their combined fields. From a quantum view, forces arise from the exchange of particles.
(22:13) The concept of force via particle exchange is illustrated with covalent bonds, where the "hopping" of an electron between two atoms creates an attractive force. Similarly, the electrostatic force is described as the exchange of photons between charged particles.
(34:56) The lecture starts to catalogue the elementary particles, acknowledging that the Standard Model is complex and somewhat messy ("an ugly monstrous mess") because we don't fully understand why these specific particles exist.
(38:38) The first particles listed are the photon, the quantum of the electromagnetic field, and the electron. The properties of each particle, such as mass, charge, and spin, are detailed.
(49:32) Quarks are introduced as the fundamental constituents of heavier particles like protons and neutrons. They come in six "flavors" (up, down, strange, charm, bottom, top) and have fractional electric charges.
(1:11:15) It is explained that a proton is composed of two up quarks and one down quark, while a neutron is made of one up quark and two down quarks. Their properties are derived from these constituents.
(1:24:00) The lecture introduces mesons, which are particles made from a quark-antiquark pair. Examples include pions (made of up and down quarks/antiquarks) and kaons (which contain a strange quark).
Isospin is introduced by analogy to spin. Color is introduced as a solution for the existence of delta particles (uuu), which would otherwise have all quarks in the same state - illegal for fermions. Gluons properties are describe by analogy to quark antiquark pairs.
Topics:
The mathematics of spin
Isospin
Color, quarks, and gluons
Summary:
Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD): The lecture introduces QCD as the theory that describes the interactions of quarks and gluons. This is analogous to Quantum Electrodynamics (QED), which describes the interactions of electrons and photons.
Hadrons, Baryons, and Mesons: The particles made of quarks and gluons are called hadrons. These are further divided into baryons (like protons and neutrons, made of three quarks) and mesons (made of quark-antiquark pairs).
Spin and Isospin: The concept of spin, a quantum-mechanical property of particles, is reviewed. A similar concept, isospin, is introduced to describe the symmetry between up and down quarks. For example, the proton and neutron are considered an isospin doublet, meaning they are like two different states of the same particle.
The Delta Puzzle: The lecture highlights a particle called the Delta, which is composed of three up quarks with their spins aligned in the same direction. This presented a problem because it appeared to violate the Pauli exclusion principle, which states that no two identical fermions can occupy the same quantum state.
Color Charge: The solution to the Delta puzzle is the introduction of a new quantum number called "color." Quarks come in three "colors" (red, green, and blue), which allows the three quarks in the Delta to be distinguished from one another.
Gluons: Gluons are the force-carrying particles of the strong interaction, similar to how photons carry the electromagnetic force. There are eight types of gluons, and they are responsible for binding quarks together.
Gluon Self-Interaction: A crucial difference between gluons and photons is that gluons themselves carry color charge. This means that gluons can interact with each other, which is not the case for photons. This self-interaction is a key feature of QCD.
Frequency-Dependent Mass: The lecture touches on the idea that the mass of a quark is not a fixed value but depends on the energy of the interaction it is involved in.
This is the first of two lectures focusing on group theory. Basic concepts of group theory are introduced and connected to particle properties like spin and color.
Topics:
Groups and symmetries
Group representations
Group generators
Spin
Rotation groups
Color
Summary:
Rotations as a Group: The lecture begins by describing spatial rotations as a non-abelian (non-commutative) group. A rotation can be defined by an axis and an angle, requiring three parameters.
Matrix Representations: Rotations can be represented by 3x3 matrices that act on vectors. A defining property of these matrices is that they preserve the length of the vector, which mathematically means the matrix multiplied by its transpose equals the identity matrix (RᵀR = 1).
Connection to Quantum Spin: This concept is linked to quantum mechanics, where rotations affect the spin of a particle. The three states of a spin-1 particle transform under rotations just like the three components of a vector, so they are described by a three-dimensional representation.
Spin-1/2 Particles and SU(2): For a spin-1/2 particle, which has two states (up and down), rotations are represented by 2x2 complex matrices. To preserve probability, these matrices must be unitary (U⁺U = 1). Adding the condition that their determinant is 1 defines the Special Unitary group SU(2), which is the three-parameter group that describes rotations for spin-1/2 systems.
Generators of Rotations: The generators of infinitesimal rotations in the SU(2) group are the traceless, Hermitian Pauli spin matrices (Sigma matrices).
Introducing Color and Quarks: The lecture shifts to quarks, which have a property called "color" (red, green, and blue). This is a three-state system, analogous to how spin is a two-state system.
The SU(3) Symmetry of QCD: The physics of quarks is required to be invariant under the mixing of these three colors. This symmetry is described by the Special Unitary group SU(3), which consists of 3x3 unitary matrices with a determinant of one.
Parameters and Gluons: The SU(3) group is an eight-parameter group. This number corresponds to the eight gluons, which are the force carriers in quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of the strong nuclear force.
Professor Susskind continues developing group theory, making connections from group generators and subgroups to particles. Gluons properties are explored with this framework, including confinement of quarks.
Topics:
Group generators
Group representations
SU(3) / color
Gluons and confinement
Summary:
This lecture provides an overview of the Standard Model of particle physics, with a focus on group theory, SU(3) symmetry, and the principles of quantum chromodynamics (QCD).
Here is a summary of the key points from the lecture:
Group Theory in Physics: The lecture begins by explaining how abstract mathematical groups and their representations are fundamental to quantum mechanics. For instance, the SU(2) group, representing rotations in space, acts on the spin of an electron, which is a two-state system (spin up, spin down).
Symmetries and Generators: Symmetries in physics lead to conserved quantities. The "generators" of a symmetry group, which describe infinitesimal transformations (like a tiny rotation), correspond to these conserved quantities. For the rotation group, the generators are the angular momentum operators.
Introducing SU(3) and Color Charge: The lecture transitions from the SU(2) rotation group to the SU(3) group, which is the foundation of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of the strong nuclear force. In this context, quarks come in three "colors" (red, green, blue), and the SU(3) operations mix these colors.
Combining Particles and Representations: When combining particles, their representations are combined. For example, taking a quark (in the 3 representation) and an antiquark (in the 3-bar representation) can produce a color-neutral state called a singlet (1) and a color-charged octet (8).
The Building Blocks of Matter: The theory postulates that quarks transform as a triplet (3), antiquarks as an anti-triplet (3-bar), and gluons (the force carriers of the strong force) as an octet (8).
Color Confinement: A central rule of QCD is that all observable, free particles must be color singlets (color-neutral). This explains why we don't see individual quarks or gluons. These singlets are formed in two main ways:
Mesons: Composed of a quark and an antiquark.
Baryons: Composed of three quarks (e.g., protons and neutrons).
The Strong Force and Flux Tubes: The reason for confinement is the nature of the strong force. Unlike the electromagnetic force, which weakens with distance, the force between quarks remains constant as they are pulled apart. The gluon field lines form a "flux tube" that stores energy, making it impossible to separate a quark from its partners. Trying to do so only creates new quark-antiquark pairs.
The Standard Model: The lecture concludes by placing QCD within the larger framework of the Standard Model, which is described by the symmetry group SU(3) x SU(2) x U(1). This encompasses the strong force (SU(3)), weak force (SU(2)), and electromagnetism (U(1)).
Professor Susskind describes the concept of a gauge field and it's associated symmetries. Symmetries lead to conserved charges like the electric charge and color. These concepts are used to describe the weak interaction.
Topics:
Gauge fields and symmetries
Charges
The weak interaction
Feynman diagrams for the weak interaction
Summary:
This lecture provides an overview of gauge theories, focusing on the Standard Model of particle physics, including electromagnetism, the strong interaction, and the weak interaction.
Gauge Theories and Electromagnetism (00:50): The lecture begins by introducing gauge theories as the foundation of modern particle physics, with Maxwell's theory of electromagnetism serving as the simplest example. It explains that fields like the electric and magnetic fields can be described by a four-vector potential, and that the mathematical structure of the theory, known as Gauss's law, leads directly to the principle of electric charge conservation.
Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) (14:17): The discussion moves to the strong force, described by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). This theory is based on a more complex SU(3) symmetry group. In QCD, quarks possess a "color" charge (red, green, or blue), and the force is mediated by eight types of particles called gluons.
Gluon Self-Interaction (26:42): A crucial difference between electromagnetism and QCD is that gluons, unlike photons, carry the charge of the force they mediate (color charge). This means gluons can interact with each other, leading to much more complex dynamics and phenomena like quark confinement, where quarks are permanently bound together inside particles like protons and neutrons.
Interaction Strength and Coupling Constants (30:01): The lecture explains that the strength of these forces is determined by a dimensionless "coupling constant." For electromagnetism, the fine-structure constant is small (about 1/137), making it relatively weak. For the strong force, the equivalent coupling constant is much larger, which is why it's called the "strong" interaction.
The Weak Interaction (33:23): The weak interaction is introduced, characterized by its extremely slow processes, such as the decay of a neutron, which takes about 12 minutes. These long decay times indicate the "weakness" of the force.
Quark and Lepton Families (55:40): The fundamental particles are organized into families of quarks and leptons. The weak force acts on pairs, or "doublets," within these families, such as the up and down quark, or the electron and its neutrino.
W and Z Bosons (1:03:33): The weak force is also a gauge theory (based on the SU(2) group) and is mediated by gauge bosons known as the W+, W-, and Z bosons. Unlike photons, the W bosons are charged.
Mediating Particle Decay (1:09:33): The W boson facilitates the transformation of one type of particle into another. The lecture illustrates how the decay of particles like the pion, muon, and neutron can be understood as a fundamental particle emitting a W boson, which then decays into other particles (e.g., a down quark in a neutron emits a W- boson, turning into an up quark, and the W- boson then decays into an electron and an anti-neutrino).
In this lecture Professor Susskind continues with the weak interaction, answering the question "Why is the weak force weak?" He connects this to the form of the propagator in Feynman diagrams. The lecture ends with the introduction of explicit and spontaneous symmetry breaking.
Topics:
Why is the weak force weak?
Propagators
Explicit and spontaneous symmetry breaking
Summary:
Symmetries of the Standard Model: The lecture explains the fundamental symmetries of the Standard Model. SU(3) is the color symmetry of the strong force (QCD), which mixes the three colors of quarks (red, green, and blue). SU(2) is the flavor symmetry of the weak force, which transforms quarks within the same family (e.g., up and down quarks).
Gauge Bosons as Force Carriers: Gauge bosons are the physical manifestations of these symmetries. The emission of a gluon (the gauge boson for SU(3)) changes the color of a quark. Similarly, the emission of a W boson (a gauge boson for SU(2)) changes the flavor of a quark.
The Standard Model Gauge Group: The Standard Model is described as a gauge theory based on the mathematical group SU(3) x SU(2) x U(1). SU(3) represents the strong force, SU(2) represents the weak force, and U(1) represents the electromagnetic force, mediated by the photon.
The Weakness of the Weak Interaction: The weak interaction is "weak" not because its fundamental coupling constant is small, but because its force-carrying particles, the W and Z bosons, are extremely massive.
Particle Propagators and Mass: The probability of a force being mediated is described by a "propagator." For a massive particle like the W boson, the propagator's value is inversely proportional to the square of its mass. This large mass in the denominator significantly suppresses the strength of the weak force over distance.
Fermion and Lepton Families: The lecture outlines the organization of fundamental particles into three families or generations of quarks and leptons. Each family is a heavier version of the one before it. Leptons, unlike quarks, do not carry color charge and thus do not participate in the strong interaction.
Virtual Particles and the Uncertainty Principle: Processes that seem to violate energy conservation, like a neutron decaying into a proton by emitting a heavy W boson, are possible because the W boson is a "virtual particle." According to the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, it can exist for an extremely short time by "borrowing" the necessary energy.
Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking: The concept of spontaneous symmetry breaking is introduced as a situation where the underlying laws of a system are symmetric, but the system's lowest energy state (the ground state) is not. This is a crucial concept for understanding how particles acquire mass.
The Higgs Boson: The lecture concludes by mentioning that the Higgs boson is associated with a form of spontaneous symmetry breaking, which is the mechanism responsible for giving elementary particles their mass.
In this lecture Professor Susskind shows how spontaneous symmetry breaking in a field theory can lead to the creation of Goldstone bosons like the photon and gluons.
Topics:
Spontaneous symmetry breaking
Local variation of gauge invariance - Goldstone bosons
Covariant derivative
Summary:
Spontaneous vs. Explicit Symmetry Breaking: The lecture begins by distinguishing between two types of symmetry breaking. Spontaneous symmetry breaking is when the underlying laws of a system are symmetric, but the system's lowest energy state (or ground state) is not. This is illustrated with an analogy of magnets that prefer to align in the same direction, either all up or all down, despite there being no inherent difference between up and down. Explicit symmetry breaking, in contrast, occurs when an external factor, like a magnetic field, directly favors one state over another.
Domain Walls: A key characteristic of spontaneous symmetry breaking in systems with discrete symmetries (like up/down) is the existence of domain walls. These are boundaries that form between regions where the system has settled into different ground states.
Continuous Symmetries: The discussion then shifts to continuous symmetries, where configurations can be interpolated smoothly. An example is a complex field that can be rotated by any angle in a plane, described by the U(1) symmetry group.
Goldstone Bosons: When a continuous symmetry is spontaneously broken, it gives rise to massless particles known as Goldstone bosons. These correspond to long-wavelength, low-energy excitations along the directions of the broken symmetry, like moving along the bottom of the "Mexican hat" potential. Spin waves in a ferromagnet are given as a physical example.
Gauge Invariance: The lecture introduces gauge invariance, a powerful principle stating that the fundamental laws of physics should not change when symmetry operations are performed locally (i.e., vary from point to point in spacetime). Initially, the theory is not invariant under these local transformations.
Gauge Bosons and Covariant Derivatives: To restore symmetry under local transformations, a new field—a gauge field (like the electromagnetic field)—must be introduced. This leads to the replacement of ordinary derivatives with covariant derivatives, which include a term for the gauge field, ensuring the full theory remains gauge invariant. This process naturally describes the coupling of charged particles to gauge fields like the photon.
Mass and Gauge Invariance: A critical consequence of gauge invariance is that it forbids adding a simple mass term for the gauge boson (like the photon) by hand, as this term would break the symmetry. This implies that gauge bosons must be massless.
The Higgs Phenomenon: The lecture concludes by setting the stage for the Higgs phenomenon. It explains that by combining spontaneous symmetry breaking with a gauge theory, it's possible for the gauge boson to acquire mass. The spontaneous breaking of the electroweak symmetry gives mass to particles like the Z boson and simultaneously removes the otherwise present Goldstone boson. This mechanism is fundamental to the Standard Model.
The Goldstone boson gets eaten, giving mass to the gauge boson via the Higgs field.
Topics:
Spontaneous continuous symmetry breaking
Local variation of gauge invariance - Goldstone bosons
The Higgs particle
Covariant derivative
Summary:
[00:47] The lecture explains the Higgs phenomenon, which describes how particles like the W and Z bosons acquire mass. It uses the simpler case of the photon to illustrate the underlying principle of spontaneous symmetry breaking.
[02:08] In certain conditions, like inside a superconductor, the U(1) gauge symmetry associated with electromagnetism is spontaneously broken, causing the photon to behave as if it has a mass.
[05:33] A key distinction is made between massless and massive particles based on their energy-momentum relationship. Massless particles, like photons in a vacuum, have zero energy at zero momentum. Massive particles have a non-zero rest mass, which is their energy at zero momentum.
[14:31] In a field with a "Mexican hat" potential, two types of excitations arise. The oscillation in the radial direction is the massive Higgs boson, while the oscillation along the circular minimum of the potential is the massless Goldstone boson.
[15:18] The central concept of the Higgs mechanism is that the massless Goldstone boson is "eaten" by a massless gauge boson. This interaction causes the gauge boson to become massive.
[32:14] The principle of gauge invariance is crucial. While the laws of physics are symmetric under a global phase shift of a field, they are not symmetric under a local (position-dependent) phase shift unless a compensating gauge field (like the photon's vector potential) is introduced.
[51:20] To maintain gauge invariance with local phase shifts, the standard derivative is replaced by a covariant derivative. This new derivative incorporates the gauge field, ensuring the theory's equations remain consistent under these transformations.
[1:08:18] When symmetry is spontaneously broken, the scalar field acquires a non-zero value in its lowest energy state. Plugging this value into the covariant derivative term in the Lagrangian naturally generates a mass term for the gauge boson.
[1:11:36] The Goldstone boson effectively disappears as a physical particle because its variations become indistinguishable from a gauge transformation. It is absorbed to become the third, longitudinal polarization state of the newly massive gauge boson.
[1:22:23] Ultimately, no degrees of freedom are lost. The system starts with a two-component scalar field and a massless, two-polarization gauge boson (4 degrees of freedom) and ends with the Higgs boson and a massive, three-polarization gauge boson (also 4 degrees of freedom).
Professor Susskind continues his description of the Higgs mechanism focusing on giving mass to fermions.
Topics:
The weak interaction is left handed
Coupling fermions to the Higgs
Gauge fields
Summary:
The Higgs Mechanism and Mass: The lecture explains how the Higgs field gives mass to particles. (00:05) The Higgs field has a "Mexican hat" potential, and its non-zero value in the vacuum (spontaneous symmetry breaking) is what gives mass to particles like the W and Z bosons. The search result from Glasp further clarifies that in the Standard Model, the Higgs field is a complex scalar field, and the W and Z bosons acquire mass when the Goldstone boson is "absorbed" by them. (L7.1 Higgs Physics: Higgs Mechanism | Video Summary and Q&A)
Mass as Energy at Rest: From a field theory perspective, mass is the energy a field has when it's uniform and not changing in space. (13:24) If a field only has energy when its value changes from point to point (i.e., it has derivatives), then its corresponding particle is massless, like the photon.
Left-Handed and Right-Handed Particles: Fermions, like electrons, can be "left-handed" or "right-handed" depending on the relationship between their spin and direction of motion. (26:38) The weak interaction, responsible for processes like beta decay, is fundamentally asymmetric: it only interacts with left-handed particles. This is a key feature of the Standard Model. Glasp provides an interesting article on how this asymmetry could be used to communicate with extraterrestrial intelligence. (How to Tell Matter From Antimatter | CP Violation & The Ozma Problem | Summary and Q&A)
Fermion Masses and the Higgs Field: Because the weak interaction only affects left-handed particles, a direct mass term in the equations would violate fundamental symmetries. (38:26) The Higgs field solves this problem by coupling left-handed and right-handed particles. The strength of this coupling, called the Yukawa coupling, determines the mass of the fermion.
Yukawa Couplings and the Hierarchy of Masses: The wide range of fermion masses (from the light electron to the heavy top quark) is explained by a corresponding range of Yukawa couplings. (57:38) The lecture explains how these couplings can be experimentally tested by observing the decay of the Higgs boson.
The Origin of Mass: A striking conclusion of the Standard Model is that all known fundamental particles would be massless if not for the Higgs field. (1:15:14) Their masses are a direct consequence of the spontaneous symmetry breaking of the Higgs field.
Neutrinos and the Mayorana Particle: Neutrinos are a special case. Because they have no electric charge, it's possible for a left-handed neutrino to turn into a right-handed anti-neutrino, giving it a special kind of mass. (1:12:55) A particle that is its own antiparticle is called a Mayorana particle.
The final lecture returns to renormalization, the mass of fermions, the W boson and the expected mass scale of the Higgs. Professor Susskind finishes with the running of the coupling constants and the interesting fact that they appear to unify at an energy scale of 10^16 GeV.
Topics:
Renormalization
The Lagrangian for the Dirac equation (handedness)
The W boson and mass scale for Higgs boson
The running of coupling constants and unification
Gravity at short distances
Summary:
Unification of Forces: The lecture begins by posing the idea of unifying the fundamental forces (strong, weak, and electromagnetic) into a single, larger mathematical structure, such as the group SU(5).
The Dirac Equation and Mass: The Dirac equation's Lagrangian is explained, highlighting that the mass term is what mixes or flips the left-handed and right-handed components (chirality) of a particle. A massless particle would have a definite, unchanging handedness.
The Higgs Mechanism: To give particles mass without violating charge conservation in weak interactions (which only couple to left-handed particles), the Higgs field is introduced. Fermions gain mass by interacting with the Higgs field, which has a non-zero value in the vacuum due to spontaneous symmetry breaking.
Yukawa Couplings: The strength of the interaction between the Higgs field and each fermion is determined by a unique "Yukawa coupling" constant. The mass of each quark and lepton is directly proportional to its Yukawa coupling, explaining the wide range of particle masses observed.
The "Mexican Hat" Potential: The spontaneous symmetry breaking of the Higgs field is caused by its unique potential energy shape, often called a "Mexican hat" potential. This potential has its minimum value away from zero, forcing the field to acquire a non-zero vacuum expectation value.
Running Coupling Constants: The strength of fundamental forces is not constant but changes with distance or energy scale. This phenomenon, known as "running," is due to the screening effect of virtual particles in the vacuum. For example, the electric charge appears stronger at shorter distances.
Grand Unification: When the coupling constants of the strong, weak, and electromagnetic forces are extrapolated to very high energies, they appear to converge to a single value. In supersymmetric theories, this convergence is remarkably precise, suggesting a unification of these forces at an energy scale of about 10¹⁶ GeV.
Gravity at the Planck Scale: The lecture explains that gravity, though weak at everyday scales, becomes incredibly strong at very small distances. Its force law changes, causing it to become comparable in strength to the other forces at the Planck scale, hinting at a total unification.
The Hierarchy Puzzle: The conclusion raises a fundamental puzzle in physics: why is the energy scale of the Higgs field and weak interactions (around 200 GeV) so incredibly small—15 orders of magnitude smaller—than the natural scale of unification and gravity (the Planck scale)?.